Gear PDW Stock Buyer’s Guide Dave Merrill February 23, 2017 2 Comments, Join the Conversation At RECOIL, we review every product fairly and without bias. Making a purchase through one of our links may earn us a small commission, and helps support independent gun reviews. Learn More We’ve heard it said, “The shorter and more useless a rifle is, the more a soldier wants it.” To some extent, it’s true that an extremely short rifle will always hold some appeal; we’ll readdress the “useless” portion later in this piece. While, no doubt, someone has built a stubby version of just about any rifle ever made (to include the archaic Mosin-Nagant), we’re going to specifically focus on the AR-series of rifles. One of the easiest ways to reduce the overall length (OAL) of an AR is to simply shorten the barrel. And indeed, legally registered short-barreled rifles (SBRs) have gained in popularity over the years — with barrel lengths getting smaller and smaller as time goes on. However, there’s still more that can be done on the buttstock end of things, but herein is where the AR-15 presents some unique challenges. A PDW stock does not a perfect system make. As you no doubt already know, the operating mechanism of a standard AR involves the inclusion of a receiver extension (more commonly known as the “buffer tube”) and the requisite buffer and spring housed inside it. This adds a considerable amount of length to the overall system. There are some modified rifles on the market that don’t utilize a receiver extension, but they’re outside the realm and scope of this buyer’s guide.Though variations have existed for decades, the personal defense weapon (PDW) stock for the AR-15 is now more desirable than ever. Unfortunately, not all of them are created equally. In order to reduce the OAL, some changes have to be made to the rifle’s operation. This can be accomplished in a few different ways, with some even requiring proprietary bolt carrier groups. Every PDW stock, sans one, in this buyer’s guide necessitates, at minium, an atypical buffer, spring, and receiver extension.Some stocks trade a little extra length for more flexibility, while others strive for the shortest, stubbiest rifle possible. If a proprietary bolt carrier is used, changing calibers or using it in a non-DI-operated AR may be troublesome, and even without adding special carriers, running alternate calibers may not be possible with every PDW shown. If one is considering a PDW project, it should be done with eyes wide open. Due to the unique nature of the buffer/spring combinations used by PDW stocks, fine-tuning of the action almost always takes place on the front end. Usually this comes down to gas adjustment or specific load development; though sometimes gas boosters, such as the Noveske KX5, come into play. As mentioned, swapping calibers can also add a layer of complexity — once we start severely reducing the gas system length, your options get limited quickly. As such, a PDW project can be a joy or an exercise in frustration.One absolutely could finagle a PDW stock on a 16-inch barreled AR-15, but it would look weird as hell. PDW stocks are typically considered for barrels shorter than 10.3 inches, with some even less than 7.5 inches.Regarding the useless aspect: Speaking specifically of 5.56 NATO, it’s indeed true that traditional loads require high velocities to achieve primary wounding mechanics. However, advances in powder and projectile technology have resulted in loads that provide decent performance even in the [sometimes severely] reduced velocity environment of a short-barreled rifle. The TL/DR version is this: A PDW is all about compromise and bargaining. The shorter the barrel, the more considerate one has to be regarding ammunition selection.PISTOLSIf you’re running a pistol instead of a legally registered short-barreled rifle, that doesn’t mean you’re completely out of the PDW game. Most of the options on this list come in both stock and brace form.Many can be swapped out between the brace and stock assembly once your Form 1 clears, assuming you’re going the SBR route in the first place.USING THIS BUYER'S GUIDENot every PDW stock on the market is represented in this buyer’s guide. There are new examples produced on a regular basis and likely some updated versions of what you see here. But they’re all based on the same theme. Use this guide to determine the most important aspects for you and compare any new options in the future to these established PDW stocks. When assessing overall weights of a system, take note whether a proprietary bolt-carrier group (BCG) is included. Those that don’t include specialized BCGs may appear lighter in the specs, but weights usually even out when this necessary part is added. Some of the stocks have different buffer/spring options, and these will also be noted. All of the lengths and weights provided result from our own measurements not from the manufacturer’s spec sheet.BEST PDW STOCKS AND BRACESSafety Harbor Firearms Kompact Entry Stock (KES)OAL Open: 10.25 inches OAL Closed: 4.5 inches Weight: 30.3 ounces Stock Positions: 2 Sling Attachment Points: 2 (slot-type) Proprietary BCG (Y/N): Yes MSRP: $350 URL: www.safetyharborfirearms.comThe Safety Harbor KES is a different take on the proprietary bolt carrier/buffer. Unlike other one-piece units, the specialized buffer can be removed from the rear of the BCG. The special receiver extension is torqued in place with a very large hex wrench (included), rather than being secured with a castle nut.We found assembly of the receiver halves to be relatively straightforward; push the separate buffer back into the receiver extension while shotgunning the receivers together. But disassembly requires the removal of both pins.Safety Harbor currently has variations with or without QD mounts, and specific versions for the SIG MPX and MCX.Troy PDW Stock KitOAL Open: 8.75 inches OAL Closed: 4 inches Weight: 29 ounces Stock Positions: 6 Sling Attachment Points: 2 (QD-type) Proprietary BCG (Y/N): Yes MSRP: $499 URL: troyind.comTroy PDW Stock Kit $299.00 palmettoarmory.comThe Troy PDW Stock kit is very similar to the NEA CSS, but with some improvements. Though it maintains the BCG/buffer combination with similar assembly/disassembly procedure, there are many more stock positions available and the receiver extension can be locked down using a hex nut. The Troy PDW stock kit is also noteworthy because it includes a complete BCG instead of a stripped one, and the stock adjustment button is ambidextrous.Maxim Defense CQB Stock Gen 7OAL Open: 10 inches OAL Closed: 5.5 inches Weight: 23.2 ounces Stock Positions: 4 Sling Attachment Points: 2 (QD-type) Proprietary BCG (Y/N): No MSRP: $450 URL: www.maximdefense.comMaxim Defense PDW Stock Kit $339.99brownells.comThe Maxim Defense CQB stock is the first PDW stock in the roundup that doesn’t require a proprietary bolt carrier; it also provides the most buffer weight options. Maxim Defense stocks are available with seven different buffer configurations to accommodate a myriad of calibers and cyclic rates: three using shortened JP Enterprises Silent Captured Springs, and four using special short buffers of different weights.Because the Maxim Defense CQB stock doesn’t use a proprietary BCG, take down and assembly is the same as a standard AR-15, though the buffer retention pin and spring aren’t required if using one of the modified JP Enterprises captured springs. There’s no provision for a castle nut, but a standard stock wrench works to tighten the receiver extension. Though two QD-type sling attachment points are standard, the company has additional QD points and positions available as add-on accessories. It’s with noting the LOP is preset with a hex screw and repositioned by pushing a button.MVB Industries Original ARC StockOAL Open: 8.75 inches OAL Closed: 5 inches Weight: 28.4 ounces Stock Positions: 2 Sling Attachment Points: 1 (QD-type) Proprietary BCG (Y/N): No MSRP: $435 URL: mvbindustries.comThe MVB Industries ARC stock definitely has some unique features. First, it features a two-piece receiver extension with dual nesting buffer springs. Though it doesn’t have a proprietary carrier group, the MVB ARC has a buffer that tucks into the rear end of a standard BCG. The receiver extension can be torqued in place with a standard carbine buffer tube wrench.The ARC stock also features a buffer lock button, allowing for standard separation and reattachment of the receivers though disassembly using the buffer lock takes a little practice to master. The example we have is only two-position, but a multi-position version is available. Currently, MVB offers five different buffer weights for the MVB ARC, and specific stock versions for both 9mm and 7.62NATO.Armaspec XPDW Gen 2OAL Open: 10.25 inches OAL Closed: 7 inches Weight: 23 ounces Stock Positions: 5 Sling Attachment Points: 1 (QD-type) Proprietary BCG (Y/N): No MSRP: $220 URL: armaspec.comArmaspecXPDW $170.99 brownells.comThe Armaspec XPDW is the only product in our roundup that doesn’t require either a proprietary carrier or buffer/spring system. Hell, it doesn’t even require a special receiver extension. That’s because the XPDW bolts right to your existing setup. Simply remove your current buttstock (assuming that you’re running a Mil-spec six-position tube), slide on the XPDW, and bolt it into place. It doesn’t make the rifle any shorter than a normal buttstock, but instead just provides the look and styling of a PDW.Strike Industries PDW StockOAL Open: 11 inches OAL Closed: 7.5 inches Weight: 20 ounces Stock Positions: 2 Sling Attachment Points: None Proprietary BCG (Y/N): No MSRP: $275 URL: StrikeIndustries.comWhile not the most sexy looking stock on the market, the Strike Industries PDW works well and is very compact while not requiring anything proprietary or converting anything you already own. This is a drop-in replacement for the system you already have and uses the existing BCG. Limitations to that is that this is not compatible with lightweight BCGs or most 9mm systems with the exception of Angstadt Arms 9mm and PSA 9mm PCCs.Major benefit to the Strike PDW is that it is comfortable to use, far more so than it looks. More on AR-15 Tuning and BuildsheetsMK18 Tuning and Development Solvent Traps, and DIY Suppressors with JK Armament Tactical Tailor's Low Profile SBR Bag SBR Ammo Buyer's Guide What is an SBR, and why it Matters.Explore RECOILweb:SilencerCo - the Harvesters (and how suppressors work)Seeing helps the believing - Aero Precision's M4E1 Enhanced Upper ReceiverStarter: Thai Style Venison Salad (Larb)The Ashley Update: Rare Assault Rifles NEXT STEP: Download Your Free Target Pack from RECOILFor years, RECOIL magazine has treated its readers to a full-size (sometimes full color!) shooting target tucked into each big issue. Now we've compiled over 50 of our most popular targets into this one digital PDF download. From handgun drills to AR-15 practice, these 50+ targets have you covered. Print off as many as you like (ammo not included). Get your pack of 50 Print-at-Home targets when you subscribe to the RECOIL email newsletter. We'll send you weekly updates on guns, gear, industry news, and special offers from leading manufacturers - your guide to the firearms lifestyle.You want this. Trust Us.
I wish you guys had put a table at the end that showed the specs listed throughout, and gave a ratio between OAL and collapsed length. Otherwise an excellent article.
